Stop the Presses – This will kill you!

As many of you know I have a  hard time joining the bandwagon for fads, poor science and bad research studies/interpretations. Alex Hutchinson writes some pretty good stuff for Runners World. Most recently he wrote about a controversial study that has been bandied about in the press over the past couple years. The study used flawed statistics that lead them to the conclusion that basically stated very little running is bad for you and that running can shorten your life. Study conclusions have to be closely scrutinized. Just a few considerations…

  • What population is studied? (i.e. results of sedentary adults may have no relationship to active adults)
  • Was it a study of non-runners (other sports)? (i.e. basketball or soccer as related to distance runners)
  • Is there a built-in bias from the researchers? (i.e. almost all studies end up finding what they are looking for; sponsored research by-product manufacturers find their product “works”)
  • Has the study been replicated? (i.e. sometimes anomalies happen even with controls – replicating minimizes that chance)
  • Are there controls or control groups? (i.e. the Placebo Effect is alive and well)

Sometimes studies are well designed, use proper statistical and control techniques to show valid results which can indeed guide us to better training. Even then it is the over-reaching application of results that can be in err. Here is a good example of that big research revelation about sitting too much that has a balanced view (see his summary paragraph if you don’t want to read his entire evaluation of the data and corroborating studies). And here is another balanced take on the static stretching pre-workout research. Note in the end he owns his interpretation while substantiating his reason.

I know that media sources and the advent of electronic media and media sharing get a lot of the blame. But media – no let me rephrase that – reporters and writers love cool things to report on. It’s like a popularity contest. So before you take the next exercise research revelation to heart – consider not only the media source but the author as well. I will tend to buy into someone’s point who has knowledge and balance. I think Hutchinson has it right when he states, “The cooler and less probable the result, the more we should suspend our judgment until others can verify it.”

 

Advertisements

About Dean Hebert

I’m a mental game coach, author and speaker. I work with individual athletes, parents, coaches, and teams on sports performance enhancement. Beyond my academic post-graduate work in sports psychology - the psychology behind athlete performance – I am a certified Mental Games Coaching Professional (MGCP) and certified hypnotherapist. I’ve authored several books and hundreds of articles. “Coach, I didn’t run because…” (2008) is a seriously light-hearted look at making excuses not to workout and how to overcome them. “Focus for Fitness” (2009) and “Screw the Goals Give me the Donut” (2010) are two of my eBooks on mental game approaches for the everyday athlete. I wrote these because I believe that everyone can benefit from the powerful mental techniques that the world’s best athletes use. I have been cited in Runners World, Best Health magazine (CN), SWEAT Magazine, and the Washington Examiner amongst many other publications. I have been a featured mental games coach in Runner’s World and for the internationally acclaimed trail running resource - trailrunningclub.com. I also regularly appear on sports and fitness talk shows such as LTKFitness, Runnersroundtable and for more than three years I have co-hosted a weekly video series with Coach Joe English for Running-Advice.com. I specialize in mental toughness training. My clients include tennis, synchronized swimming, golf, race-kart, soccer, motocross, volleyball, MMA, cycling (road, off-road, time-trialist), running, duathlon and triathlon, basketball, football and baseball athletes. I have coached world-class athletes and athletes internationally. I have a passion for working with youth athletes and helping them apply mental game skills and techniques to all areas of life. Most importantly, my aim is to have people enjoy sports and life to their fullest through peak performances.
This entry was posted in aqua running, Blogroll, College Running, Confidence, Cramps, Excuses not to run, Exercise Research, focus, Goal Setting, Heat Training, High Intensity Interval Training, HIIT, Illness and Running, Lyme Disease, Marathon, Mental Game, Mental Game Boot Camp, Mental Toughness, Mobile App, Motivation, Muscle Cramps, Pacing & Running, Plantar Wart, Racing Flats, Range of Motion, Running, Running & Diet, Running Camps, Running Humor, Running Records, Running Shoes, Running Streaks, Sports Psychology, Stretching, The Running Life - Philosophy, Track and Field, Track Terminology, Training Effectiveness, Ultra-Marathon, Youth Athletes, Youth Running and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s